| 2024 | Marshall | Paulson Stadium | W 24-23 | White Helmet (2024) | White | White |
| 2023 | Marshall | Joan C. Edwards Stadium | L 33-38 | Blue | White | Blue - GATA (2021-22) |
| 2023 | James Madison | Bridgeforth Stadium | L 13-41 | Blue | Blue | White |
| 2023 | Coastal Carolina | Paulson Stadium | W 38-28 | Blue - USA (2023) | Blue | White |
| 2022 | Buffalo | Cramton Bowl | L 21-23 | Blue | White | Blue - GATA (2021-22) |
| 2022 | South Alabama | Paulson Stadium | L 31-38 | Blue - USA (2022) | Blue | Gray - GATA (2020-22) |
| 2022 | Old Dominion | S.B. Ballard Stadium | W 28-23 | Blue | White | Blue - GATA (2021-22) |
| 2022 | Georgia State | Center Parc Stadium | L 33-41 | Blue | White | Blue - GATA (2021-22) |
| 2022 | Coastal Carolina | Brooks Stadium | L 30-34 | Blue | White | Blue - GATA (2021-22) |
| 2022 | UAB | Protective Stadium | L 21-35 | Blue | White | Blue - GATA (2021-22) |
| 2022 | Nebraska | Memorial Stadium | W 45-42 | Blue | White | Blue - GATA (2021-22) |
| 2021 | Appalachian State | Kidd Brewer Stadium | L 3-27 | Blue | White | Blue - GATA (2021-22) |
| 2021 | Coastal Carolina | Paulson Stadium | L 8-28 | Blue - USA (2021) | Blue | White |
| 2020 | Troy | Paulson Stadium | W 20-13 | Blue - Chrome GATA (2020) | Blue | Gray - GATA (2020-22) |
| 2020 | South Alabama | Paulson Stadium | W 24-17 | Blue - USA (2020) | Blue | White |
| 2020 | Massachusetts | Paulson Stadium | W 41-0 | Blue | White | White |
| 2019 | Liberty | Exploria Stadium | L 16-23 | Blue - Cure Bowl (2019) | Blue | White |
| 2019 | Troy | Memorial Stadium | L 28-49 | White - Winged (2019) | White | White |
| 2019 | Appalachian State | Kidd Brewer Stadium | W 24-21 | White - Winged (2019) | White | White |
| 2019 | Coastal Carolina | Paulson Stadium | W 30-27 | Blue - USA (2019) | Blue | White |
| 2019 | LSU | Tiger Stadium | L 3-55 | Blue | Blue | White |
| 2018 | Appalachian State | Paulson Stadium | W 34-14 | Blue - Chrome Eagle (2018) | Blue | Gray Pants |
| 2017 | South Alabama | Paulson Stadium | W 52-0 | Gray - USA (2017) | Blue | White |
| 2017 | New Mexico State | Paulson Stadium | L 27-35 | Blue - Erk Tribute (2017) | Gray - Erk Tribute (2017) | Gray - Erk Tribute (2017) |
| 2016 | Georgia Tech | Bobby Dodd Stadium | L 24-35 | Blue | Blue | White |
| 2016 | Western Michigan | Waldo Stadium | L 31-49 | Blue | Blue | White |
| 2016 | Savannah State | Paulson Stadium | W 54-0 | Blue - Gold Rush (2016) | Blue - Gold Rush (2016) | Gold - Gold Rush (2016) |
| 2015 | Appalachian State | Kidd Brewer Stadium | L 13-31 | White Helmet (2015) | White | White |
| 2015 | New Mexico State | Paulson Stadium | W 56-26 | White - GS Logo (2015) | Blue | White |
| 2014 | Idaho | Paulson Stadium | W 47-24 | Gray - Traditions (2014) | Gray - Traditions (2014) | Gray Pants |
| 2014 | Georgia Tech | Bobby Dodd Stadium | L 38-42 | Blue | Blue | White |
| 2013 | Western Carolina | Paulson Stadium | W 35-19 | Blue - Teachers (2013) | Blue - Teachers (2013) | Gray Pants |
| 2012 | Wofford | Paulson Stadium | W 17-9 | Blue - Military Appreciation (2012) | Blue - Military Appreciation (2012) | White |
| 2011 | Samford | Seibert Stadium | W 31-17 | Blue | Blue | White |
| 2009 | Furman | Paulson Stadium | L 22-30 | Blue | Blue | Blue Pants |
| 2009 | Elon | Rhodes Stadium | L 14-28 | Blue | White | Blue Pants |
| 2008 | Appalachian State | Paulson Stadium | L 36-37 | Blue | Blue | Blue Pants |
| 1999 | Appalachian State | Kidd Brewer Stadium | L 16-17 | Blue | White | Blue Pants |
| 1998 | Massachusetts | Finley Stadium | L 43-55 | Blue | Blue | Blue Pants |
| 1998 | Furman | Paladin Stadium | W 45-17 | Blue | White | Blue Pants |
| 1998 | Appalachian State | Paulson Stadium | W 37-24 | Blue | Blue | Blue Pants |
| 1997 | Furman | Paulson Stadium | W 30-13 | Blue | Blue | Blue Pants |
| 1997 | Chattanooga | Paulson Stadium | W 37-10 | Blue | Blue | Blue Pants |